Arrest of Ian B.: video analysis
Published on
On 28 September 2019 in Montpellier, Ian B., a member of the Désarmons-les collective, was arrested during a Yellow Vests demonstration. Sentenced in 2020 to eight months in prison for violence against a police officer, he is retried on Tuesday 17 November before the court of appeal. The synchronised footage of the scene shows him pushing aside with his hand the shield of a police officer who had just struck an observer from the Ligue des droits de l’Homme (French Human Rights League).
- Incident date
- Location
- Montpellier (France)
- Victim(s)
- Ian B.
- Force(s) involved
- National Police
- Methods employed
- Beating
- Theme(s)
On 28 September 2019, during Act 46 of the Yellow Vests movement in Montpellier, Ian B. was arrested near the Polygone shopping centre. A member of the Désarmons-les collective, which documents the weapons used in policing and supports people who have been injured, he was charged with violence and contempt against a person holding public authority, as well as with joining a group with a view to committing violence, according to Reporterre. He was also charged with refusing to give a DNA sample, Basta! adds. Index synchronised two of the videos filmed that day, including the one from the camera held by an observer from the Ligue des droits de l’Homme (LDH), to retrace how the scene unfolded.
What the footage shows
According to the police officer who was the civil party, Ian B. kicked and punched him and insulted him; no total incapacity for work was recorded, Basta! notes. The footage shows a different sequence: a police officer strikes the LDH observer with his shield; Ian B. steps forward and pushes the shield away with the flat of his hand. A few seconds later, after a police officer points at him, he is charged and pinned to the ground. No punch or kick on his part can be seen in the videos, and none of the officers present wears a visible RIO identification number.
A retrial on appeal
On 3 December 2020, the Montpellier criminal court sentenced him to eight months in prison, without immediate committal, and ordered him to pay 600 euros in damages to the police officer who was the civil party, Le Poing reports. The prosecution had asked for five months. Jean-Jacques Gandini, of the LDH, noted at the time that it is rare for a court to go beyond the prosecution’s request.
The observer filed a complaint with the IGPN, the police oversight body, against the officer with the shield. According to Jean-Jacques Gandini and a statement from Désarmons-les, the court refused to view these videos and relied solely on CCTV stills. The collective describes the police reports as false. After his conviction, Ian B. spoke to Basta! about his arrest and the hearing.
More than seven years after the events, Ian B. is retried on Tuesday 17 November at 2 pm, in room 109 of the Montpellier court of appeal. His supporters are calling for a rally outside the court from 1 pm.