The bill passed by 205 votes to 110, according to France 24. The National Assembly had adopted it at first reading on 7 July, after the government rewrote it: it no longer refers to self-defence, but provides that law enforcement officers are presumed to have acted within the law when they use their weapon. What it changes in investigations into police shootings was set out while the bill was being examined.

Police unions welcomed the vote. Many human rights organisations, including Amnesty International France and the Ligue des droits de l’Homme, describe the text as a permis de tuer, a “licence to kill”. Amnesty points out that since the 2017 law that widened the conditions for using firearms, fatal shootings of people inside vehicles have increased fivefold. The National Consultative Commission on Human Rights (CNCDH) had also warned members of parliament in June. On 14 November, at the call of the collective Stop aux violences d’État, marches against the bill took place in several cities.

The Constitutional Council, the final step

The left-wing groups in the Senate have announced that they will refer the law to the Constitutional Council. Such a referral, open to sixty members of the National Assembly or sixty senators, suspends the promulgation of the law. The Council then has one month to rule: it may uphold the text, strike it down in whole or in part, or uphold it subject to interpretative reservations, which are then binding on the judges handling investigations into police shootings.

It is the last means of preventing the text from coming into force. Once the law is promulgated, it can only be challenged through a priority question of constitutionality (QPC), raised in the course of a case — that is, after a first police shooting covered by the presumption of legality.