Police violence: two convictions and a dismissal in three days
Published on
On Friday 20 November, three police officers were convicted of the racist assault on Michel Zecler in Paris, and a fourth for the shooting that killed Jean-Paul Benjamin in Aulnay-sous-Bois, without being sent to prison. Two days earlier, it emerged that the investigation into the death of Ibrahima Bah in Villiers-le-Bel had been closed with a dismissal, seven years after the events.
From left to right: Michel Zecler after the verdict; undated portrait of Ibrahima Bah, known as “Ibo” (Bah family); undated portrait of Jean-Paul Benjamin (Benjamin family).
The three cases date back to 2019, 2020 and 2022, and were decided by three different courts. In both trials, CCTV footage weighed against the officers’ version: it contradicted the report written after the assault on Michel Zecler, and led the court to reject the self-defence claimed by the officer who killed Jean-Paul Benjamin. In the third case, the judicial investigation ends without a trial, despite a reconstruction that Ibrahima Bah’s family considers damning.
Michel Zecler: racism upheld
The Paris departmental criminal court convicted the three officers who beat Michel Zecler at the entrance to his studio in November 2020, after a check for not wearing a mask. They were found guilty of intentional violence and forgery of a public document: their report accused Michel Zecler of hitting them, which CCTV footage contradicted. Sentences range from one year under electronic tagging to two years in prison, below the four to six years sought by the prosecution.
The significance of the ruling lies above all in the aggravating circumstance of racism, which the court upheld even though the investigating judges had dismissed it: Michel Zecler says he was called a “sale nègre” (a racist slur) during the assault. His lawyers see it as a first in this kind of trial. The court also found that the forged report discredited the officers’ denials.
Jean-Paul Benjamin: self-defence rejected, no imprisonment
In Bobigny, the Seine-Saint-Denis departmental criminal court found Emmanuel Neves, 37, a former senior officer of the Aulnay-sous-Bois BAC (anti-crime brigade), guilty of intentional violence causing death without intent to kill, for shooting dead Jean-Paul Benjamin, 33, in his van in March 2022. After reviewing the CCTV footage, the court rejected the self-defence he claimed. It sentenced him to five years in prison, three and a half of them suspended, meaning eighteen months to serve, without immediate detention, and permanently barred him from the police. The prosecution had sought five years. The court took his “service record” into account; Jean-Paul Benjamin’s family, who had denounced the failings of the investigation, left the courtroom in anger.
Two days earlier, in Nanterre, the Hauts-de-Seine assize court of appeal had sentenced to eight years and sent back to prison the officer who killed Olivio Gomes in 2020. The two cases do not involve the same charge — murder in one, violence causing death in the other — nor the same court. What they share is a shooting at a motorist and a rejected claim of self-defence.
Ibrahima Bah: case dismissed for the three officers
On 18 November, AFP revealed that an investigating judge in Pontoise had issued a dismissal (non-lieu) in favour of the three officers, who had the status of assisted witnesses, in the judicial investigation for involuntary manslaughter opened after the death of Ibrahima Bah. The 23-year-old died on 6 October 2019 in Villiers-le-Bel (Val-d’Oise), in a motorbike accident involving a police van. According to a source close to the case quoted by AFP, the judge ruled out any collision between the bike and the van, and found it was not established that the van’s manoeuvre was intended to block his path.
In a statement, the family points out that the reconstruction revealed inconsistencies, that the officers’ statements changed, and that the traffic island the van driver said he was trying to avoid does not exist — as was observed on site during the reconstruction. It notes that the decision comes after seven years of proceedings, and that it was issued by the fourth investigating judge assigned to the case. Their lawyer, Vincent Brengarth, told AFP the decision was “appalling” and announced an appeal; the officers’ lawyer, Louis Cailliez, said the court had recognised his clients’ “innocence”. The appeal will be heard by the investigating chamber of the Versailles court of appeal.